Review
for the Generalist
Lyme borreliosis
(disease) in children and adolescents
Prof. Dr. med. Hans-Iko Huppertz
Hans-Iko Huppertz
Klinikum Bremen-Mitte
Professor-Hess-Kinderklinik
Sankt-Jürgen-Strasse
28205
Lyme borreliosis
is a vector borne disease transmitted by ticks of the Ixodes genus. These ticks include Ixodes ricinus (
Lyme disease is named after the small
town of
However, it was only after the
description of Lyme disease in the
Ixodes rizinus and other species, the transmitting ticks, evolve by
metamorphosis through three stages. The smallest one is the larva which feeds
on small mammals, for example mice, and then develops in the humid ground to a
nymph which, after another blood meal, develops in the ground to an adult
animal. The adult animals are bisexual, survive in the fur of large animals
like deer during wintertime, and then, after another blood meal, copulate in
spring and the female lays eggs in the ground, which then develop into larvae. Borrelia burgdorferi
is not transmitted transovarially, but is transmitted
transstadially. So when larvae get infected with Borrelia burgdorferi,
nymphs and adults will be infected as well. The larva usually acquires the
infection from mice in which Borrelia burgdorferi maintains spirochetemia.
Often larvae feed in late summer, while nymphs feed in early summer. So mice
have gotten the infection with Borrelia burgdorferi from nymphs and transmit it to larvae later
in the year. Human beings are usually bitten by nymphs and sometimes by larvae
and rarely by adult ticks. [2-3,12-14]
The tick bite is often not
recognized, in part because the animals are so small. [12] Other reasons are
the special components found in tick saliva. Although it is called tick “bite”,
it is more like a sting, when an elongated part from the tick’s mouth is pushed
through the epidermis into the skin where it is rotated to form a lake of
ruptured vessels. The tick’s saliva contains local anesthetics, so that the
host does not feel pain. Since saliva also contains antihistamines, anti-C3,
anti-TNF-a and anti-neutrophil
substances, there is neither an allergic nor an inflammatory reaction against
the tick or its products. In addition, saliva contains antithrombotic
substances so that the tick can suck blood for a long time; usually it feeds
between 3 and 5 days. [15]
Borrelia burgdorferi is a spirochete which, due to its small size, is not
visible by microscopy, except for phase contrast microscopy, when Borrelia can be seen because of its ability to move.
Several genotypes have been described including Borrelia burgdorferi sensu
stricto (in a strict sense), Borrelia afzelii and Borrelia garinii all of which are part of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato (in the broad sense).
Although Borrelia burgdorferi sensu stricto is associated with
arthritis, Borrelia garinii with
central nervous system involvement and Borrelia afzelii with acrodermatitis chronica atrophicans, all species
may also lead to other manifestations and the distinction between the different
species is of limited clinical importance. [4]
Clinical manifestations in children
and adolescents vary from what is described in adult humans (Table 1). [12-14]
Table 1: Clinical manifestations of Lyme borreliosis in children and
adolescents.
|
Early (days, weeks) |
Late (months, years) |
Erythema migrans
Lymphocytoma |
Acrodermatitis chronica
atrophicans |
|
Lymphocytic meningitis Facial palsy |
Radiculoneuritis Encephalomyelitis |
|
Myopericarditis |
Cardiomyopathy |
|
Conjunctivitis |
Uveitis, Keratitis |
|
Summer “ flue” Arthralgias |
Episodic
arthritis Chronic
arthritis |
The most frequent pediatric manifestations are printed
in bold letters.
Pediatric Lyme
borreliosis usually is divided into early and late
manifestations. Early manifestations occur days to weeks after the infection,
are self-limiting and do not lead to permanent organ damage. Late
manifestations occur months to years after infection; they may become chronic and
may lead to permanent organ damage. Early manifestations can disappear by
itself without any further disease, but they may also progress to late
manifestations. Late manifestations may occur in the absence of early
manifestations. Although some patients have several manifestations of the
disease, usually patients have just one of the late manifestations. [2-3,12-13]
The most frequent manifestation of Lyme borreliosis is erythema migrans, an expanding
reddish lesion starting at the site of the tick bite. The erythema
enlarges during the next days to an oval or round spot of several cm of
diameter with a black point in the middle, the site of the tick bite, and an
accentuated margin and a pale centre of the lesion. Figure 1 Erythema chronicum migrans rash on a child’s legs

In some patients, several erythemata migrantia occur, which
are not due to several tick bites but due to early spread of Borrelia burgdorferi. (Figure
1) These children often have lymphocytic meningitis
in addition to multiple erythemata migrantia. Lymphocytic meningitis
with or without facial palsy is the most frequent neurological manifestation in
children and adolescents. Other cranial nerves may be involved as well. In
spite of lymphocytic pleocytosis,
often, the patient has an only marginally stiff neck, but headaches, nausea and
constitutional symptoms. [12-13]
The most frequent late manifestation
of Lyme borreliosis is
arthritis, in 2/3 of the patients as episodic arthritis. In episodic arthritis,
the patient has arthritis for a few days to 2 weeks and then it disappears by
itself. After a symptom free interval of a few weeks to months, arthritis
recurs, usually in the same joint. After several episodes, arthritis may
disappear or become chronic (duration of uninterrupted arthritis of 3 or more
months). Nearly all patients with Lyme arthritis have
involvement of the knee joint during their disease; 2/3 have monarthritis. Often there is a large effusion with little
pain. Most patients do not remember a tick bite and very rarely there is a
preceding erythema migrans.
This is a consequence of early antibiotic treatment of patients with erythema migrans which prevents
progression of the disease to late Lyme borreliosis. [16-17]
Sometimes patients with Lyme arthritis may also have eye disease. The iridocyclitis may be indistinguishable from what is seen in
patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis. Uveitis intermedia may lead to severely impaired vision. More
frequently, eye disease occurs in the absence of arthritis and encompasses
conjunctivitis as an early manifestation and, in addition to the above
mentioned manifestations, keratitis as a late
manifestation. [18-20]
The disease is prevalent in nearly
all European countries, in some areas of North-America and in parts of
The disease is acquired in spring,
summer and autumn, usually when surface temperature is above 10 – 15 degrees
Celsius. [2,4,24-25] Most patients, up to 90 %, have erythema
migrans. [2-3,13-14] Therefore the disease is most
prevalent in spring to autumn. However, some cases start in wintertime. They
usually have late Lyme borreliosis
like Lyme arthritis which has a long and varying
incubation period. In contrast to tick borne central European encephalitis, a viral
disease, which is transmitted by the same ticks, Lyme
borreliosis is not acquired at special, sometimes
remote, sites during leisure time, but is acquired during daily life-activities
close to the sites where patients live. It may be acquired also in municipal
parks and in the front garden of town houses. [13,25]
Diagnosis is made by clinical
evaluation alone or with support of additional laboratory results. Laboratory
values should not be obtained in the absence of a clear clinical suspicion of Lyme borreliosis. Available
laboratory methods include culture of borrelias,
which is rarely efficient due to the fastidious nature of Borrelia
burgdorferi, the long culture period of 4 – 6 weeks
and the low number of organisms present in body fluids. Tissue staining with
monoclonal antibodies is rarely efficient because of the low number of
organisms. Lymphocyte transformation assay has been shown to be less sensitive
and less specific than serology. [5,12,13]
So far polymerase chain reaction
(PCR) is difficult to handle outside research laboratories. Usually it is
recommended to analyze more than one body fluid with several primers including
bacterial chromosome and plasmids. In addition, tissue specimens, for example
from the joint, might be a better medium for PCR than synovial
fluid. PCR under these conditions has been found positive in patients with Lyme arthritis in synovial fluid
in up to 80% and in lymphocytic meningitis from
cerebrospinal fluid in up to 25%. So serology cannot be substituted by PCR. A
positive PCR from a good laboratory supports the diagnosis Lyme
borreliosis, a negative PCR is of no consequence.
[3,12-13]
The usually performed serological
tests are enzyme-immuno-assays for IgG and IgM antibodies to Borrelia burgdorferi.
Since they are screening assays, they are often false positive. Therefore, if
enzyme-immuno-assays are positive, they have to be
confirmed by immunoblot-/Western blot-assays. There
are no standardized rules for interpretation; however, in whole-cell blots, 2
bands of the IgM blot and 6 bands of the IgG blot usually are required to confirm positivity. [26-28]
Erythema migrans
is diagnosed by clinical means only and there is no need for serological
confirmation. Indeed, serologic tests often are still negative in the presence
of early infection and thereby might confuse physician and patient alike. In
rare cases of atypical presentation, PCR from skin biopsy could be considered.
In my opinion, this skin biopsy is more invasive than a therapeutic attempt
with a short course of antibiotic treatment. In all other manifestations,
laboratory confirmation of the clinical suspicion of Lyme
borreliosis should be sought. [29]
In the case of Lyme
arthritis, a clinical score has been developed for the diagnosis. [30]
Comparing clinical data of patients with Lyme
arthritis with those of patients presenting with other causes of arthritis, it
was found that patients with Lyme arthritis more
frequently remember a tick bite, more frequently have episodic arthritis, more
frequently start with arthritis of the knee joint and less frequently complain
of arthralgias initially. In addition, they are older
and have a smaller number of large joints involved. By combining these six
items, a score has been elaborated which allows for the exclusion of Lyme arthritis or confirmation of Lyme
arthritis in 2/3 of cases, in the absence of the knowledge of serological
results. This example of a clinical score, based solely on data obtained by
history and physical examination, shows the importance of the clinical
evaluation of a child when assessing the patient for the presence of Lyme borreliosis. Only in the
presence of clinical evidence for Lyme borreliosis, serological tests for antibodies to Borrelia burgdorferi
should be performed. [30]
While diagnosis of Lyme borreliosis may be difficult
in some cases, treatment usually is easy. Erythema migrans is treated for 2 – 3 weeks by doxycycline
200 mg/day in children 9 years or older. In younger children amoxicillin 50
mg/kg in 3 doses is given. When erythema migrans disappears rapidly, 2 weeks of treatment are
sufficient. If disappearance is slow, the treatment should be prolonged for a
week. If it is still present after 2 weeks of treatment, the diagnosis should
be questioned. [31-33]
All other manifestations can be
treated by ceftriaxone 50 mg/kg/day (maximum 2 g/d)
for 14 days by intravenous route. Since it is applied just once per day, we
continue treatment in the outpatient department if the patient’s social context
allows this or when the patient has recovered from neuroborreliosis.
While neuroborreliosis should always be treated by
intravenous means, Lyme arthritis may also be treated
by oral antibiotics, amoxicillin for 4 weeks or doxycycline
for 4 weeks at the same doses as mentioned above. It is important to assure a
good compliance which might be difficult using amoxicillin because 3 doses per
day have to be given for 28 days at predefined time points. We have had
favorable experiences with the combination of roxythromycin
(5mg/kg) plus cotrimoxazol (6 mg/kg) in 2 doses for 4
weeks, when patients did not respond to ceftriaxone.
Although 1 antibiotic treatment should be sufficient for eradication of borrelias, we recommend 2 courses, usually with different
drugs, if the first treatment is not effective within 6 weeks of initiation
(see table 2). [34]
Table 2: Antibiotic treatment of Lyme
borreliosis
|
Drug |
Dosage per day in doses |
Maximum dose/day |
Duration [weeks] |
|
Amoxicillin |
50 mg/kg in 3 |
2 g |
EM: 2-3; LA: 4 |
|
Doxycyclin1 |
200 mg in 1 |
200 mg |
EM: 2-3; LA: 4 |
|
Ceftriaxone |
50 mg/kg in 1 |
2 g |
2 |
|
Cefotaxime |
150 mg/kg in 3 |
6 g |
2 |
|
Roxythromycin;
Cotrimoxazol2 |
5 mg/kg in 2; 6 mg/kg in 2 |
300 mg; 360 mg |
4 |
|
EM: erythema migrans; LA: Lyme arthritis amoxicillin, doxycycline,
and roxythromycin + cotrimoxazol
are given by mouth, ceftriaxone and cefotaxime are given intravenously. Neuroborreliosis
should always be treated intravenously. |
|||
Not all children with Lyme arthritis respond to antibiotic treatment. One year
after initiation of antibiotic treatment, between 10 and 20% of patients still
have arthritis or arthralgias, mostly in the joints
that have been affected previously by arthritis. Risk factors for an antibiotic
refractory course are treatment with steroids, especially intraarticular
steroids, prior to initiation of antibiotic treatment, older age (10 years or
older in comparison to younger age), female gender and long duration of
arthritis before initiation of antibiotic treatment, i.e. more than 6 months.
[32]
When antibiotic treatment fails in
patients with Lyme arthritis, antirheumatic
treatment may be initiated. Intraarticular steroids
may be tried, while non-steroidal antirheumatic drugs
usually are of little help. In case of failure of intraarticular
steroids, methotrexate or other second line antirheumatic drugs may be tried. Finally synovectomy in combination with intraarticular
steroids remains an option for refractory cases. [35]
Prognosis in general is excellent
and finally arthritis will disappear. However, we have observed relapses for up
to 3 years after disappearance of arthritis. Antibodies may remain high in
spite of lasting clinical remission; therefore induction of remission is not
assessed by serology but by clinical means only. [36]
The histological picture of chronic Lyme arthritis is indistinguishable from changes found in
juvenile idiopathic arthritis: Synovial hypertrophy, lymphocytic infiltration and high vascularization.
[37] Although it is close to impossible to culture Borrelia
from joint tissue, the organism has been demonstrated by tissue staining and
PCR. [38-39] In an in vitro model, synovial cells
could be infected by Borrelia burgdorferi
and Borrelia persisted intracellularly
even in the presence of antibiotics in the surrounding medium. [40]
If Borrelia burgdorferi is an intracellular bacterium, CD8+ cytotoxic T-cells should be present in patients with Lyme arthritis. In fact, CD8+ HLA class I-restricted
T-cells, specific for particular antigens of Borrelia burgdorferi, could be found. However, lytic activity of these cells appeared only after
disappearance of arthritis. As a consequence the authors suggested that CD8+ cytotoxic T-cells are necessary for eradication of Borrelia burgdorferi.
However, these cells are suppressed in case of ongoing arthritis either by
persistent infection or by purely immunological means. [41]
There are several theories trying to
explain the pathogenesis of chronic and treatment-resistant Lyme
arthritis. Besides persistent infection, the most probable theory is
autoimmunity. One proposed autoimmune mechanism is molecular mimicry of Borrelia OspA, a bacterial
surface antigen, and human LFA-1, a T-cell antigen. [42] Recently, some authors
who had put up this theory several years ago have backed away from it.
Moreover, immunopathological reactions due to
lipoproteins, abundant at the surface of Borrelia burgdorferi, might be responsible for
chronic arthritis. [42]
Several means of prevention have
been proposed. While it is possible to avoid states and areas with a high
incidence of Lyme borreliosis
in the
Therefore, the best means of
prophylaxis is to remove an attached tick as early as possible. The reason for
the prophylactic value of early removal of the tick is as follows: Borrelia burgdorferi
lives in the midgut of the tick. Only when the host’s
blood enters the tick’s midgut, after the beginning
of a blood meal, Borrelia burgdorferi
starts to proliferate, perforates the gut wall and enters the hemolymph, a kind of blood of the tick. Borrelia burgdorferi then enters the salivary
glands of the tick, and finally, borrelias are
excreted via these glands into the host. This process takes some time, in an
animal model nearly 36 hours. So prompt removal of the attached tick within 24
hours of attachment is the best available protection against Lyme borreliosis. If children are
assessed each night before going to bed, the time of attachment in most cases
is very short. Removal of ticks should not be performed with nail polish, glue,
rotation of the tick or other manipulations, but by drawing slowly with
instruments or finger nails without compressing the animal’s body. It may take
up to 90 seconds till the tick withdraws its mouthparts from the host and then
comes off the skin. After tick removal the bite site should be disinfected. [1]
Summary
References:
randomized
comparison of ceftriaxone and penicillin. Lancet 1988
May 28;(8596):
1191-4.
33. Weber K, Preac-Mursic
V, Wilske B. A randomized trial of ceftriaxone versus oral
penicillin
for acute neurological manifestations in Lyme Borreliosis. A prospective
randomized
study. Infection 1990;18:91-96.
Allergologie und Immunologie, 3rd ed. Urban & Fischer München, 1999, pp 598-602.
outcome 12 months
after the initiation of antibiotic therapy. J Rheumatol
2000;
27:2025-2030.
lesions.
Am J Pathol. 1985;118:26-34.
burgdorferi in joint fluid in chronic Lyme arthritis. Ann Intern Med. 1986 Jun;104
(6):798-800.
39. De Koning J, Bosma RB, Hoogkamp-Korstanje JAA. Demonstration of spirochetes
in
patients with Lyme disease with a modified silver
stain. J Med Microbiol. 1987;23:
261-267.
40. Girschick
HJ, Huppertz HI, Russmann
H, Kreen V, Karch H.
Intracellular persistence
of
Borrelia burgdorferi in
human synovial cells. Rheumatol
Int. 1996;16(3):125-32.
41. Busch DH, Jassoy C, Brinckmann
U, Girschick H, Huppertz
HI. Detection of Borrelia
burgdorferi-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T cells in patients with Lyme
arthritis. J Immunol.
1996 Oct 15;157(8):3534-41.
42. Bolz
DD, Weis JJ. Molecular Mimicry to Borrelia burgdorferi: pathway to
autoimmunity?
Autoimmunity 2004 Aug;37(5):387-92.